| 研究生: |
許鶴齡 Hsu, Ho-ling |
|---|---|
| 論文名稱: |
國際間制止索馬利亞海盜政策之研究
兼論我國應有之作為 A Research of International Community's Policy to Suprress Somali Pirates - What Taiwan Should Do |
| 指導教授: |
陳怡凱
Chen, Yi-Kai |
| 學位類別: |
碩士 Master |
| 系所名稱: |
工學院 - 海洋科技與事務研究所 Institute of Ocean Technology and Marine Affairs |
| 論文出版年: | 2011 |
| 畢業學年度: | 99 |
| 語文別: | 中文 |
| 論文頁數: | 154 |
| 中文關鍵詞: | 索馬利亞 、失敗國家 、海盜 、聯合國海洋法公約 |
| 外文關鍵詞: | Somalia, Failed States, Piracy, United Nations Convention on the Law of the Seas. |
| 相關次數: | 點閱:147 下載:0 |
| 分享至: |
| 查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
西印度洋及亞丁灣海域之海盜暨武裝劫掠船隻行為是近年來海事保安之重大議題,其成因起源於索馬利亞共和國自1991年後中央政府瓦解,國內進入無政府狀態,在政府失能、連年戰亂、人民生活困苦、遭遇乾旱、外海非法漁捕活動頻繁及地利之便等原因所致,本研究之重點以瞭解索馬利亞海盜之成因並分析國際間因應海盜問題之作為是否適切為主,並兼論我國應有之作為。
觀察索國海盜之成因,重點在於索國成為失敗國家後,國家的行為能力喪失,造成索國無法行使其在國際法上的權利及義務,聯合國等國際組織為了維護區域安全情勢及照顧索國人民之人權而干涉索國,企圖治理索國以維持國家之基本功能。因此制止海盜之作為可分為兩個面向:第一個是幫助索國的人道援助、加強索國自身之能力及促進其國內派系之和解;第二點則是以法律為依據之打擊海盜措施,《聯合國海洋法公約》對海盜之行為有所定義,國際應該以此定義為海盜罪之標準,輔以聯合國安全理事會之決議等法律文件;最後筆者將透過海軍政策之學理解說各國派遣海軍之背後因素,並分析各國參與打擊海盜之海上武力資料。本研究歸納出國際的人道救援仍然有限,無法幫助索國廣大區域上之所有人民(尤其是海盜猖獗區域);和平倡議無法解決索國分裂之事實;各國對海盜罪之規範必須更新至可滿足起訴索國海盜;各國應該擴大海上軍事行動之合作,並以新的戰術及佈署較輕量型之戰艦來打擊海盜;而我國面對此議題不可保持沉默,在能力及經費之許可下應該有所作為,並藉此事件參與國際合作。
國際社會在面臨索國海盜帶來挑戰的同時,必須體會到索國海盜並非一朝一夕就能制止的。打擊海盜應該透過更多的努力並雙管齊下,從海盜之根源著手(治本)並改善打擊海盜之策略(治標)以維護相關各行為主體之利益。
Piracy and armed robbery against ship in West Indian Ocean and Gulf of Aden became the major issues on maritime affairs these years, the case originated since Somalia Central Government collapsed in 1991, the domestic situation turn into anarchy. By the functions of the government was totally out of working, long time civil war, hardship environment for living, famine because of drought, IUU fishing and the geographical position make the piracy existence and getting worse. This study referred to the cause of Somali Piracy and estimate International`s currently act against the Somalia Piracy what is right and what can be improved? What should Taiwan do as an International member will also discuss in the end.
After observing all reasons that cause of Somali Piracy, the point is after Somalia became a failed state, it can`t perform the basic functions of governance, made Somalia could not exercise rights and duties from international law. Trying to governance and keep the basic functions of a government, the United Nations has intervened in Somalia for maintaining the regional security situation and the human rights. The ways we suppressing Piracy off Somali Coast can divided into two aspects: humanitarian aids, capacities building and promote reconciliation to Somali factions can be the first aspect; the second is combating Somalia Piracy in accordance with legitimacy, the United Nations Conventions on the Law of the Sea provides a definition for piracy and international subjects should take this definition as criterion against the pirates, legal documents like United Nations Security Council Resolution can assist the legal framework too. The author also trying to find out the political factors that push States deployment of navy by naval policy theory and analysis the naval forces sent to counter piracy. This study conclude that: (1) the humanitarian aids is still limited, it can`t help all the refugees in Somalia(especially the piracy rampant areas);(2) The Peace Process is not the solution for Somali`s secession;(3) States who wants to prosecute pirates should update their domestic pirate code;(4) States should collaborate in naval operations, sharing intelligence each other, deploy lighter warships and take new tactics to deter and reduce the threat posed by pirates;(5) Finally, Taiwan should not keep silence at this issue, we need some actions under permissible abilities and budgets, as an opportunity to cooperate with international communities.
Facing challenges from piracy off the Somalia Coast, international communities should realize piracy won`t be ended in short term. It should take actions under both two aspects that the author mentioned at the beginning, to erase the causes of piracy and improve the counter piracy strategy. International communities must protect the interests of all subjects while countering Somali piracy.
參考文獻
一、中文部分
(一)書籍
丘宏達(2006),現代國際法,修訂二版,台北市,三民書局,民國99
年出版。
陳勁,歐盟外交政策與對外關係,台北市,五南書局,2004年出版。
陳荔彤,海洋法論,初版,台北市,元照出版,民國九十一年七月。
陳麗娟,法學概論,二版,台北市,五南書局,2002年9月。
宋燕輝著,黃偉峰主編,〈執委會〉,歐洲聯盟的組織與運作,台北
市:五南書局,2003年出版,第201-264頁。
洪欽德,〈歐盟憲法之法理分析〉,歐盟憲法,台北,中央研究院歐
美研究所,2007年。
周成瑜,海事刑法論,台北,學林文化事業有限公司,2003年。
周成瑜,海上犯罪與國際刑法,台北市,五南圖書出版股份有限公司,
2007年9月出版。
胡念祖,海洋政策-理論與實踐,台北市,五南圖書出版有限公司,
民國八十六年九月出版。
李美華等譯,Earl Babbie著,社會科學研究方法(上&下),時英出版
社,2004年7月出版。
吳鏘煌譯,森村宗冬著,海盜事典,台北市,霹靂新潮出版社,2008
年五月出版。
姜皇池,國際海洋法總論,一版,台北市,學林文化,民國九十年九
月出版。
江國青,聯合國專門機構法律制度研究,初版,台北市,天肯文化出
版,民國八十三年七月。
(二)、期刊
「20世紀的海上公敵:索馬利亞海盜」,尖端科技,第294期,2009
年2月號。
「馬來西亞海航直升機嚇退海盜拯救印度商船」,尖端科技,第294
期,2009年2月號。
「索馬利亞海軍護航任務對中國海軍的意義」,全球防衛雜誌,294
期,2009年2月號。
范聖孟,「論軍艦在公海上之警察權」,國防雜誌,第24卷,第三期,
頁21-40。
王偉峰,「現代海盜 今非昔比」,科學與文化,2009年,第4期,頁
4-7。
蔡裕明,「海上恐怖主義與台灣海上安全」,第四屆「恐怖主義與國家
安全」學術研討會,民國九十七年,第173-188頁。
蔡萬助,「海盜治理與亞丁灣海上安全合作機制」,第五屆「恐怖主義
與國家安全」學術研討會,民國九十八年,第123-142頁。
汪毓瑋,「海事安全脈絡下打擊海盜與海上恐怖主義之研究」,第五屆
「恐怖主義與國家安全」學術研討會,民國九十八年,第143-167頁。
林佾靜,「失敗國家與國家安全:衝擊與回應」,《全球政治評論》,第
24期,2008年11月,頁121-158。
(三)、政府出版品
外交部,中華民國九十八年世界各國簡介暨政府首長名冊,台北市,
外交部,民國九十八年四月。
國防部,中華民國九十八年國防報告書,台北市,國防部,民國九十
八年。
二、英文部分
(一)書籍
Booth Ken, Navies and Foreign Policy, (New York, HM Publishers,
Inc1979).
Cable James, Gunboat diplomacy 1919-1994, Political Applications of
Limited Naval Force, (New York : St Martin`s Press 1994).
Piracy off the Somali Coast, Final report, Assessment and
recommendations, (workshop Commissioned by the Special
Representative of the Secretary General of the UN to Somalia
Ambassador Ahmedou Ould-Abdallah, Nairobi, 2008).
(二)期刊
Beckman, Robert, ”Somali Piracy-is International Law Part of Problem or
Part of the Solution?”,(2009) available at:
http://www.rsis.edu/research/PDF/Beckman%20Somali%20Piracy
%20RSIS%2023%20Feb%202009.pdf.
Collins, Rosemary and Daud Hassan, “Applications and Shortcomings of
the Law of the Sea in Combating Piracy: A South East Asian
Perspective,” Journal of Maritime Law & Commerce, vol. 40, no.
1(2009): 89-113.
Hansen, Stig Jarle, “Private Security & Local Politics in Somalia,"
Review of African Political Economy, vol. 35, no. 118(2008):
585-598.
--------, “Piracy in the Greater Gulf of Aden," Norwegian Institute for
Urban and Regional Research, vol. 35, no. 118(2009): 1-71.
Kraska, James, “The Report on the U.S. Naval War College Workshop on
Somali Piracy, Fresh Thinking for an Old Threat,” U.S. Naval War
College (2009): 1-20.
--------. “Coalition Strategy and the Pirates of the Gulf of Aden and the
Red Sea”, Comparative Strategy, vol. 28, no. 3(2009): 197-216.
Kraska, James and Brian Wilson, “The Co-operative Strategy and The
Pirates of the Gulf of Aden”, The RUSI Journal, vol.154, no.
2(2009): 74-81.
Lesson, Peter T. “An-arrgh-chy: The Law and Economics of Pirate
Organization” Journal of Political Economy, vol. 115, no. 6(2007):
1049-1094.
Lim, Darren(2006),” United Nations Governance of Failed States:
Proposing the Foundations of a Comprehensive Framework”,
Monash University Law Review, Vol.32, No. 2, pp.296-334.
Fiske Bradley A., “Naval Policy”, The North American Review , Vol.203, No. 722, pp.63-74.
Menkhaus, Ken. “Somalia: 'They Created a Desert and Called it
Peace(building)”, Review of African Political Economy,2009, vol. 36, no. 120(2009): 223-233.
Middleton, Roger, “Piracy in Somalia, Threatening global trade, feeding
local wars”, Chatham house,(2009), available at: http://www.chathamhouse.org.uk/publications/pappers/view/-/id/665/.
Vego, Milan, ”On Naval Power” , Joint Force Quarterly, 3rd quarter, no.
3(2008): 5-25.
--------, “Counter-Piracy: An Operational Perspective”, Tidskrift i
Sjöväsendet, Issue 3(2009): 169-180.
Treves, Tullio, “Piracy, Law of the Sea, and Use of Force: Developments
off the coast of Somalia”, The European Journal of International
Law, vol. 2, no. 2(2009): 399-414.
Tripodi, Paolo and Grady Belyeu, “What happens to Somalia… Ignoring
it Is No Longer an Option”, Low Intensity Conflict & Law
Enforcement, vol. 13, no. 3(2005): 212-226.
Williams, Paul D, “Into the Mogadishu Maelstrom: The African Union
Mission in Somalia”, International Peacekeeping, vol. 16, no.
4(2009): 514-530.
一、 參考網站
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page
http://udndata.com/library/
http://www.answers.com/
http://www.imo.org/
http://www.un.org/
http://www.un.org/depts/los/index.htm
http://unpos.unmissions.org/
http://www.tfgsomalia.net/English%20Language/Home
校內:2013-02-16公開