簡易檢索 / 詳目顯示

研究生: 方汝螢
Fang, Ju-Ying
論文名稱: 我國會計師考試制度對會計教育影響之研究
指導教授: 簡金成
Chien, Chin-Chen
學位類別: 碩士
Master
系所名稱: 管理學院 - 會計學系
Department of Accountancy
論文出版年: 2003
畢業學年度: 91
語文別: 中文
論文頁數: 71
中文關鍵詞: 線性結構關係模型會計教育學習層次期望差距
外文關鍵詞: Learning Level, Accounting Education, Expectation Gap, Linear Structure Relation
相關次數: 點閱:108下載:4
分享至:
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報
  • 以往對會計教育期望差距之研究,主要圍繞在產學問對教育理念產生差異的問題上。但是隨著商業環境的變遷,會計審計人員的工作內容及角色扮演已不同於傳統;另一方面,在目前專業化、證照化的社會中,會計師考試日漸受到高等教育學子的重視。本研究只在探討在目前教育體制下造就出的大學會計系畢業生,是否符合實務界人士對其知識能力的期望?如果不符合,本研究試圖探討我國會計師考試制度是否成為會計教育的一個重要影響因素,以及會計師考試制度上存在哪些缺失造成此一期望差距產生。

    研究結果發現:
    一、目前大學會計系畢業生支實際工作表現不如執業會計師的期望,期望差距的確存在。
    二、過去十年來之會計師考試命題內容存在以下爭議:
    (一)會計師考試命題方向並不能配合實務工作之知識需求。
    (二)會計師考試命題偏重理論而忽視實務。
    (三)會計師考試測驗之學習層次偏低。
    (四)考試科目侷限於傳統會計領域,忽略非會計專業領域知識。
    (五)命題內容並未顧及資訊科技,金融創新,及其他新經濟之事對財會及管會之衝擊,僅有少數題目和當時之財經環境有關。
    三、會計師考試制度之缺失,顯著影響大學會計系畢業生之實際工作能力表現。

    The past accounting educational study of the expectation gap always concerned about the problem of the different education ideals exist between the practitioners and the educationalists. As the commercial environment change, the working content of accountants and auditors and the role they played are by far different from the traditions. On the other way, in the specialized and license focused society, the CPA Examination have been more and more noticed by the students which received the high-level accounting education. This study is in order to know “if the knowledge and capability of graduates trained from the accounting department in college match the expectation of the CPAs?” If not, the study tries to discuss that if the CPA Exam is one of the important factors effects the accounting education and what shortcomings of the examination system cause the expectation gap happened.
    The main findings are as follows.
    1. The graduates ‘performances do not match the CPAs’ expectations.
    2. The testing contents of the CPA Exam in the past decade exist the following arguments:
    (1) The testing direction cannot match the knowledge demand of the practice.
    (2) The CPA Exam always emphasizes in the theory and ignores the practice operating.
    (3) The learning level of the examination is, in general, not high.
    (4) The testing subjects limit in the traditional accounting field, and ignore the non-accounting profession field.
    (5) The testing content never covers the shocks of the information technology, the financial creating and other new economic knowledge to financial accounting and management accounting.
    3. The result of the empirical study indicates that the shortcomings of the CPA Exam significantly influence the performance of graduates.

    第一章 緒論 1 第一節 研究動機與目的 1 第二節 研究方向與研究方法 4 第三節 論文架構 5 第二章 文獻探討 7 第一節 會計專業的挑戰及改變 7 第二節 會計教育改革的需求 10 第三節 會計師考試之變革 15 第三章 實證模型、假說發展與研究方法 21 第一節 模型建立與假說發展 21 第二節 研究樣本 25 第三節 問卷設計及內容 25 第四節 問卷調查的實施 31 第四章 研究結果分析 31 第一節 會計實務界對專業發展與會計系學生之看法 46 第二節 實務界對會計師考試出題方向之意見 58 第三節 會計師考試與期望差距之關聯 63 第五章 結論與建議 63 第一節 結論 63 第二節 研究限制 65 第三節 研究建議 65 參考文獻 67

    英文文獻
    American Accounting Association. 1989. Perspectives on Education:Capabilities for Success in the Accounting Profession Big 8 White Paper. http://aaahq.org/AECC/big8/cover.htm
    American Accounting Association. 1998. The Future Viability of Accounting Education. Report of the Change Environment Committee.
    American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. 1998. The Role of Essay Questions in the Uniform CPA Examination.
    http://www.aicpa.org/members/div/examiner/download.htm
    AICPA/NASBA Guide Implementing the 150-Hour Requirement.
    http://www.aicpa.org/states/uaa/150hour.htm
    American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.,2002.Examination Reformation and Computerization http://www.aicpa.org/members/div/examiner/reforma.htm
    American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.,1997. Status Report: Updating the Uniform CPA Examination Content Specifications. http://www.aicpa.org/members/div/examiner/status/appa.htm
    Albrecht, S.W. and R. J. Sack., 2001. The perilous future of accounting education. CPA Journal,Vol.71 Issue3, p17.
    Albrecht, S.W. and R. J. Sack, Aug.,2000. Accounting Education: Charting the Course through a Perilous Future. American Accounting Association. http://aaahq.org/pubs/AESv16/toc.htm
    Anonymous.,1998. Clarifying The Course Requirements to Sit For The CPA Exam. Pennsylvania CPA Journal. Vol. 69, Iss. 1; p.28-29.
    Baker,W.M and C. C. McGregor., 2000. Empirically Assessing the Importance of Characteristics of Accounting Students. Journal of Education for Business. Vol. 75, Iss. 3; p. 149-158.
    Board of Examiners of AICPA.,2001. Practice Analysis of Certified Public Accountants. Technical Report. http://ftp.aicpa.org/public/download/members/div/examiner/parep.pdf
    Bloom,B.S.,1956. Taxonomy of Education Objectives- The Classification of Education Goals, Handbook: Conitive Domain.
    Board of Examiners of AICPA.,2002. Structure, Length, and Examination Content Specifications for the Uniform CPA Examination.
    http://www.cpa-exam.org/download/BOE%20Structure%20Length%20CSO%20Document.pdf
    Board of Examiners’ Content Oversight Content of AICPA., 2000. Uniform CPA Examination Content Specifications Update Study: General Business Knowledge Required by CPAs in Public Accounting. http://www.aicpa.org/members/div/examiner/download.htm
    Booker, Q., V.C. Brenner and J. D. Blum.,1998. Brave New World For The CPA Exam. Journal of Accountancy. Vol. 185, Iss.1; p.61-65.
    Booker, Q., J.D. Blum and T.William.,1999. The International Uniform: CPA Qualification Examination. The CPA Journal. Vol. 69, Iss. 12; p.40-44.
    Burke, J and E.T. Maccarrone., 2000. The 21st Century Exam: Uniform CPA Examination: The Only Constant is Change. The CPA Journal. Vol.70, Iss.3; p.40-45.
    Content Oversight Task Force, AICPA.,1999. CPA Business Information Survey Board of Examiners.
    http://www.cpa-exam.org/global/download/app3.doc
    Diversified Communications Group (DCG),2002. American Institute of Certified Public Accountants Revisions to CPA Examination:In-Depth Interview Research.
    Doney, L. D. and N. E. Lephardt.,1993. Developing Critical Thinking Skills in Accounting Students. Journal of Education for Business,Vol.68 Issue6,p297-301.
    Elliott, R. K., 2000. Who Are We As a Profession---And What Must We Become? Journal of accountancy. Vol. 189, Iss. 2; p.81-86.
    Escoffier, S. D., 2001.The new uniform CPA examination. The Tax Adviser. Vol. 32, Iss. 11; p.785-790.
    Flaherty,R.E.,2000, The Future of Accounting Education. Conference of Taiwan Accounting Association.
    French, G. R. and R.E. Coppage., 2000. Educational Issues Challenging The Future of The Accounting Profession. Ohio CPA Journal. Vol. 59, Iss. 3; p.69-74.
    Foster,S., B. L. Cynthia and R. H. Colson., 2002. New Competencies for Accounting Students. CPA Journal,Vol.72 Issue1,P68.
    Gabbin, A. L.,2002. The Crisis in Accounting Education. Journal of Accountancy. Vol. 193, Iss. 4; p.81- 87.
    Groenveld, B., 2001. Change In Accountant Roles Affects Education. Citybussiness. Vol. 19, Iss. 27; p.17
    Hassall,T., J. Joyce, J. L.A. Montano and J. A. D. Anes,1999. Vocational skill and capabilities for management accountants---a CIMA employer’s perspective. Management Accounting, Vol. 77, Iss. 11; p.52-55.
    Hiewu, S .,2000. An Analysis of Taiwanese University Accounting Students' Learning Styles and Learning Approaches. The 9th Accounting Theory and Practice Conference.
    Howard, R., K Anjo and I. N Gleim.,2001. Global Demand For The CPA Exam. The CPA Journal. Vol. 71, Iss. 12; p.28-33.
    Hubbard,L., 1993. Continuous Quality Improvement: Making the Transition to Education. Prescott Publishing Company. Softcover, ISBN: 0963381989
    Institute of Management Accountants,1999. Counting More, Counting Less: Transformations in the Management Accounting Profession, Montvale, NJ.:IMA
    Johnson, G.,2002. The CPA Exam Alert.
    http://www.cpa-exam.org/download/cpaex-AugSep02.pdf
    Jun, L.Z and A. Hunter.,1992. Accounting Education for the 21st Century:A Canadian Experiment. Journal of Education for Business,Vol.68 Iss.1, p38-44.
    Lakshmiu,T., 1993. JIT Can Save Accounting Education. Management Accounting, Montvale; Vol. 75, Iss. 6; p.53-56
    MacInnes,A.,2001. CPA Exam Issues Abound at Board of Examiners Meeting. Accounting Today. Vol. 15, Iss. 16; p.1-45
    Melancon,B.C., 1999. Letter From The AICPA President. Journal of Accountancy.; Vol. 188, Iss. 5; p.4-5
    Nellermoe,D.A, T.R Weirich and A. Reinstein., 1999. Using Practitioners’ Viewpoints to Improve Accounting Students’Communications Skill. Business Communication Quarterly. Vol. 62, Iss. 2; p. 41-61.
    Nellermoe,D.A., 2000. An Assessment Program For Accounting: Design, Implementation and Reflection. Issues in Accounting Education. Vol. 15, Iss. 4; p.553-582
    Person, S.,2002. Accounting Education: Charting the Course though a Perilous Future. Journal of Accountancy. Vol. 193, Iss. 4; p. 84-86.
    Stivers, B. P., J. E. Campbell and H. M. Hermanson., 2000. Fifty reasons for the decline in the quantity and quality of accounting majors. The CPA Journal. Vol. 70, Iss. 1; p.52-55.
    Sergenian, G. K. and L. W. Pant., 1998. Increasing Students' Professionalism: A Careers Project For Accounting Majors. Issues In Accounting Education. Vol. 13, Iss. 2; p.429-443.
    Siegel, G., and J.E. Sorensen., 1994. What Corporate America wants in entry-level accountants. Management Accounting, Vol. 76, Iss. 3; p.26-32.
    Sundem, G. L.,1999. The Accounting Education Change Commission:Its History and Impact. http://www.aaahq.org/pubs/history/preface.htm
    Task Force of AICPA.,2000. Uniform CPA Examination Content Specifications Update Study: General Business Knowledge Required by CPAs in Public Accounting Board of Examiners’Content Oversight http://ftp.aicpa.org/public/download/members/div/examiner/gbkfinal.doc
    Thomas C Wooten., 1998. Factors influencing student learning in introductory accounting classes: A comparison of traditional and nontraditional students. Issues in Accounting Education. Vol. 13, Iss. 2; p. 357-374.
    Vangermeersch, R.,2000. Fifty Reasons For The Decline In The Quantity and Quality of Accounting Majors. The CPA Journal. Vol. 70, Iss. 1; p.52-55.
    Whitten, D and T. Brahmasrene., 2002. Passing The Uniform CPA Exam: What Factors Matter? The CPA Journal. Vol. 72, Iss. 11; p.60-63.
    Williams, D.L,1993. Reforming Accounting Education. Journal of Accountancy , Vol. 176, Iss. 2; p76-82
    Williams, D.L.,1999. The Accounting Education Change Commission:A Retrospective. Journal of Accountancy. Vol. 176, Iss. 2; p.76-82.

    AN I N S T I T U T E OF CE R T I F I E
    中文文獻
    朱寶珠,民國83年,我國大學會計教育現況之研究,台灣大學會計研究所碩士論文。
    李子涵,民國88年,會計教育之研究-以台灣六所大學為例,淡江大學會計研究所碩士論文。
    林嬋娟,民國89年,知識經濟時代計教育之展望,會計研究月刊,181期:35-38。
    林嬋娟,民國88年,美國會計教育改革之發展,會計研究月刊,163期:25-32。
    林慶桐,民國91年,邁向新世紀--教育發展之我見,商業職業教育季刊,84期:52-57。
    林柄滄,民國89年,會計教育何去何從?,會計研究月刊,181期:39-42。
    周國華,民國81年,影響會計師考試成續的五大因素, 會計研究月刊,85期:68-73。
    周齊武、杜榮瑞、顏信輝,民國90年,從會計專業科目之期中與期末考試題探索我國會計教育強調的學習層級(一), 會計研究月刊,187期:148-152。
    周齊武、杜榮瑞、顏信輝,民國90年,從會計專業科目之期中與期末考試題探索我國會計教育強調的學習層級(二), 會計研究月刊,188期:126-132。
    周齊武、何莉芸,民國81年,整體架構在會計教育上的重要性及其培養」,會計研究月刊:81期:74-82。
    周玲台,民國82年,改善會計教育品質之道,會計研究月刊,88期:58-62。
    馬君梅,民國89年,2000年會計大趨勢,會計研究月刊:171期:12-15。
    馬君梅、馬嘉應、柯柏成,民國88年,我國會計教育產學間之認知差距剖析,會計研究月刊,163期:18-24。
    張麗珠,民國87年,以學子之觀點探討大學會計教育,東吳大學會計學系碩士班碩士論文。
    徐雪雲,民國91年,會計師高考試提之學習層次內涵及其與塊數所需求配合情形之研究, 台灣大學會計研究所碩士論文。
    陳依蘋、鄭惠之,民國90年,「五大高峰會-會計師專業的發展與未來座談會紀實」,會計研究月刊,189期:77-87。
    陳依蘋,民國83年,「會計教育2000年大趨勢」,會計研究月刊,101期:24-29。
    鄭凱文,民國90年 ,「大學會計教育人才招募與課程修正之研究 」,政治大學會計研究所碩士論文。
    謝淑惠,民國79年,「會計師高考制度終極探討&超級建言-批評是為了更好」,會計研究月刊,56期:25-32。
    謝淑惠,江金蓮,民國78年,「透視會計考試制度良窳」, 會計研究月刊,50期:19-23。
    蘇裕惠,民國89年,「 2011年會計師專業願景何處尋」, 會計研究月刊,171期:32-36。

    下載圖示 校內:2004-07-10公開
    校外:2013-07-10公開
    QR CODE