本研究為探討資訊科技做為企業消防準備之項目時，對於其所發揮之成效表現，即減少財損與人員傷亡之方面表現分析。除了確認資訊科技能替企業帶來良好成效之結果外，本研究更欲以企業傳統消防項目做比較，分析資訊科技在現況上在整體消防成效之貢獻上具有何等重要性。
在研究對象上，以中鋼保全公司為主要之研究對象，以其客戶資料與公司內部專家為主。中鋼保全公司為具有消防與科技專業結合之公司，期提供客戶具資訊科技之消防服務，且內部專家具有相關的專業知識，故其相關資料做為分析企業應用資訊科技消防的表現十分合適。除了中鋼保全公司，本研究另外加入部分企業主與政府專家做為次要研究對象，根據其經驗與看法給予研究更完整的分析觀點。在研究方法上，本研究同時採用質量化之方法。在質化部分，本研究採用深度訪談法，對相關專家進行訪問。量化的部分主要為層級分析法(Analytic Hierarchy Process, AHP)，此方法將用以分析整體消防項目之重要性，並另有二手數據分析之部分。
研究結果上，本研究認為資訊科技確實具有減少財損與傷亡的消防成效，且能達到部分過往傳統消防手段無法完成之事，具有優秀的消防成效。然而在整體的消防成效上，資訊科技尚不能與其他消防項目相比，本研究認為可能因為應用普遍度以及成本問題，使資訊科技尚無法做為比肩傳統手段的消防準備項目。

關鍵字：資訊科技、企業防災、消防安全

In purpose of assessing the effectiveness of Information Technology(IT) as a fire prevention measure for business, this research conducted both qualitative and quantitative methods to do an analysis about if IT surely mitigates fire hazard, and how it's performance compare to other measures.
This research conducted the Analytic Hierarchy Process(AHP) and in-depth interview to analysis the data form China Steel Security(CSS)、government member and business owner, to know how IT performed as a fire prevention measure. The result shows that IT is surely effective for business to enhance fire safety, but with some factors like highly cost and law requirements, IT applications are not widely applied in business for fire prevention.

Key words: Information Technology, Business Disaster Prevention, Fire Safety

參考文獻
網路資料
1. 中央通訊社2018/04/29新聞，網址：https://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/201804290222.aspx，檢索日期：2021/05/29。
2. 中央通訊社2021/05/10新聞，網址：https://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/202105100125.aspx，檢索日期：2023/03/25。
3. 中央通訊社2021/05/20新聞，網址：https://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/202105205002.aspx，檢索日期：2023/03/25。
4. 中華民國內政部消防署全球資訊網統計資料區，網址：https://www.nfa.gov.tw/cht/index.php?code=list&ids=220&page=1，檢索日期：2023/04/25。
5. 中國時報2018/08/14新聞，網址：https://www.chinatimes.com/newspapers/20180814000658-260106?chdtv，檢索日期：2023/03/25。
6. 地球黃金線2022/13/30新聞，網址： https://cars.tvbs.com.tw/car-news/93322，檢索日期：2023/05/08。
7. 林登港，2020，《消防月刊》，109年11月號，〈119 火災通報裝置誤報分析與策進建議〉，頁23-28，網址：https://monthly.nfa.gov.tw/category.php?month=11&year=109，檢索日期：2023/03/22。
8. 全國法規資料庫，《消防法》，網址：https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0120001&kw=%e6%b6%88%e9%98%b2%e6%b3%95，檢索日期：2021/03/26。
9. 全國法規資料庫，《消防法施行細則》，網址：https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0120002，檢索日期：2023/04/25。
10. 全國法規資料庫，《各類場所消防安全設備設置標準》，網址：https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0120029，檢索日期：2023/04/25。
11. 張馥暄2020/04/27新聞，鏡週刊網址：https://www.mirrormedia.mg/story/20200427soc002/，檢索日期：2021/05/29。
12. 聯合新聞網2022/11/09新聞，網址：https://udn.com/news/story/7327/6752383，檢索日期：2023/04/05。
中文部分
1. 白宏光，2005，〈PDCA方法在電子產品質量管理中的應用〉，《渤海大學學報》，26(4)：294-297。
2. 李政賢 譯，2014，Catherine Marshall and Gretchen B. Rossman 原著，《質性研究》，臺北市：五南。
3. 林金定、嚴嘉楓、陳美花，2005，〈質性研究方法：訪談模式與實施步驟分析〉，《身心障礙研究》，3(2)：122-136。
4. 林誠興、賴志忠、陳德啟、陳盈仁，2010，〈鐵皮工廠火災消防戰術評估〉，《工業安全衛生》，254：42-51。
5. 邱建國、楊國鑫、陳道平、蔡長銘、邱子熙，2015，〈臺北市企業自主型防災工作推動機制研究〉，《災害防救科技與管理學刊》，4(1)：49-75。
6. 范麗娟，1994，〈深度訪談簡介〉，《戶外遊憩研究》，7(2)：25-32。
7. 郭思餘 譯，2012，W. Lawrence Neuman 原著，《研究方法 質化與量化方法之應用》，臺北市：雙葉書廊。
8. 張可婷 譯，2013，Hennie Boeije 原著，《質性研究分析方法》，新北市：韋伯文化國際。
9. 張芬芬，2010，〈質性資料分析的五步驟：在抽象階梯上爬升〉，《初等教育學刊》，35：87-120。
10. 黃倩儀、吳百祿、莊美玲、張筱雯 譯，2003，Mildred L. Patten 原著，《研究方法》，台北市：華藤文化。
11. 楊永年，2009，〈八八水災救災體系之研究〉，《公共行政學報》，32：143-169。
12. 廖茂為。2006。新竹市火災搶救之研究。新竹市：國立交通大學碩士論文。
13. 鄧振源、曾國雄，1989，〈層級分析法(AHP)的內涵特性與應用〉，《中國統計學報》，27(6)：5-22。
14. 謝坤霖、呂亦儒，2006，〈非營利單位資訊災難備援機制建置之研究〉，《資訊管理研究》，6：81-100。
15. 羅清俊，2020，《公共政策：現象觀察與實務操作》，台北：揚智。

外文部分
1. Bajgoric, Nijaz. 2014. “Business Continuity Management: A Systemic Framework for Implementation.” Kybernetes, Volume 43(2): 156-177.
2. Bjelland, Henrik, Ove Nja, Atle William Heskestad and Geir Sverre Braut. 2015. “The Concepts of Safety Level and Safety Margin: Framework for Fire Safety Design of Novel Buildings.” Fire Technology, Volume 51: 409-441.
3. Boyce, Carolyn, Palena Neale. 2006. “Conducting In-depth Interviews: A Guide for Designing and Conducting In-depth Interviews for Evaluation Input.” Pathfinder International.
4. Burnett, Jonathan D. and Michael G. Wing. 2017. “A low-cost near-infrared digital camera for fire detection and monitoring.” International Journal of Remote Sensing, Volume 39(3): 741-753.
5. Crabtree, B. F. and W. L. Miller. 1992. Doing Qualitative Research, Sage Publications: Newbury Park.
6. Challands, Neil. 2010. “The Relationships Between Fire Service Response Time and Fire Outcomes.” Fire Technology, Volume 46: 665-676.
7. Chen, Dongjun and Hongbin Xie, 2021, “Fire Safety Evaluation for Scenic Spots: An Evidential Best-Worst Method.” Journal of Mathematics, Volume 2021:
8. Chen, Ying-Yueh, Ying-Ji Chuanga, Chin-Hsing Huang, Ching-Yuan Lin and Shen-Wen Chien. 2012. “The Adoption of Fire Safety Management for Upgrading the Fire Safety Level of Existing Hotel Buildings.” Building and Environment, Volume 51: 311-319.
9. Cheng, Min-Yuan, Kuan-Chang Chiu, Yo-Ming Hsieh, I-Tung Yang, Jui-Sheng Chou, Yu-Wei Wu. 2017. “BIM Integrated Smart Monitoring Technique for Building Fire Prevention and Disaster Relief.” Automation in Construction, Volume 84:14-30.
10. Chi, Jen-Hao, Sheng-Hung Wu and Chi-Min Shu. 2011. “A Fire Risk Simulation System for Multi-purpose Building Based Fire Statistics.” Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory, Volume 19: 1243-1250.
11. Chikoto, Grace L., Abdul-Akeem Sadiq and Erin Fordyce. 2012. “Disaster Mitigation and Preparedness: Comparison of Nonprofit, Public, and Private Organizations.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, Volume 42(2): 391-410.
12. Chu, Thuan and Xulin Guo. 2014. “Remote Sensing Techniques in Monitoring Post-Fire Effects and Patterns of Forest Recovery in Boreal Forest Regions: A Review.” Remote Sensing, Volume 6(1): 470-520.
13. Culp, Christopher L.. 2002. The Risk Management Process: Business Strategy and Tactics, John Wiley & sons: New York.
14. Chow, W. K.. 2002. “Proposed Fire Safety Ranking System EB-FSRS for Existing
High-Rise Nonresidential Buildings in Hong Kong.” Journal of Architectural Engineering, Volume 8(4): 116-124.
15. Chow, W. K.. 2005. “Building Fire Safety in the Far East.” Architectural Science Review, Volume 48(4):285-294.
16. Dushie, Daniel Yaw. 2014. “Business Continuity Planning: An Empirical Study of Factors that Hinder Effective Disaster Preparedness of Businesses.” Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development, Volume 5(27): 185-191.
17. Fadli, Lathif Hanafi and Rosalendro Eddy Nugroho. 2021. “PDCA - Eight Steps Implementation to Increasing Productivity in the Production of Compound Tread Off Road TBR.” International Journal of Research and Review, Volume 8(1): 546-560.
18. Festag, Sebastian. 2021. “The Statistical Effectiveness of Fire Protection Measures: Learning from Real Fires in Germany.” Fire Technology, Volume 57(4): 1589-1609.
19. Flynn, David T.. 2007. “The Impact of Disasters on Small Business Disaster Planning: A Case Study.” Disaster, Volume 31(4): 508-515.
20. Gibb, Forbes and Steven Buchanan. 2006. “A Framework for Business Continuity Management.” International Journal of Information Management, Volume 26(2): 128-141.
21. Gilbert, Stanley W.. 2021. “Estimating Smoke Alarm Effectiveness in Homes.” Fire Technology, volume 57: 1497-1516.
22. Ha, Sejin, Michelle Childs, Youn-Kyung Kim and Ann Fairhurst. 2020.
“After the Fire: An Assessment of Small Business Preparedness and Recovery in Gatlinburg, Tennessee.” International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Administration, Volume 21: 1-26.
23. Hardy, Gary. 2006. “Using IT Governance and COBIT to Deliver Value with IT and Respond to Legal, Regulatory and Compliance Challenges.” Information Security Technical Report, Volume 11(1): 55-61.
24. Healey, Joseph F.. 2016. The Essentials of Statistics, CENGAGE Leaning: USA.
25. Hiles, Andrew. 2010. The Definitive Handbook of Business Continuity Management, Wiley: USA.
26. Hirsch, Kimberly D and Bryan E. Strawser. 2014. “When a Drip Becomes a Flood: Lessons Learned from Target Corporation's First Large-Scale Business Disruption.” Journal of Business Continuity & Emergency Planning, Volume 8(2): 114-121.
27. ISACA. 2012. “COBIT 5: a Business Framework for the Governance and Management of Enterprise IT – an ISACA framework.” ISACA; 2012a.
28. Isniah, Sarah, Humiras Hardi Purba and Fransisca Debora. 2020. “Plan Do Check Action (PDCA) Method: Literature Review and Research Issues,” Jurnal Sistem dan Manajemen Industri, Volume 4(1): 72-81.
29. Kodur, Venkatesh, Puneet Kumarand and Muhammad Masood Rafi. 2019. “Fire Hazard in Buildings: Review, Assessment and Strategies for Improving Fire Safety.” PSU Research Review, Volume 4(1): 1-23.
30. Langmann, Bärbel, Bryan Duncan, Christiane Textor, Jörg Trentmann and Guido R.van der Werf. 2009. “Vegetation Fire Emissions and Their Impact on Air Pollution and Climate.” Atmospheric Environment, Volume 43(1): 107-116.
31. Lee, Eui-Pyeong. 2019. “Analysis of the Causes of Multiple Casualties in an Electronics Factory Fire.” Fire Science and Engineering, Volume 33(4): 130-139
32. Li, Shi-yu, Gang Tao and Li-jing Zhang. 2018. “Fire Risk Assessment of High-rise Buildings Based on Gray-FAHP Mathematical Model.” Procedia Engineering, Volume 211: 395-402.
33. Mayer, Bradley W., Jimmy Moss, Kathleen Dale. 2008. “Disaster and Preparedness: Lessons from Hurricane Rita.” Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, Volume 16(1): 14-23.
34. Merrett, Hew C. and William W. Chen. 2010. “Applications of Geographical Information Systems and Remote Sensing in Natural Disaster Hazard Assessment and Mitigation in Taiwan.” Geomatics, Natural Hazards and Risk, Volume 4(2): 145-163.
35. Montshiwa, Abednico Lopang, Akio Nagahira and Shuichi Ishida. 2016. “Modifying Business Continuity Plan (BCP) Towards an Effective Auto-Mobile Business Continuity Management (BCM): A Quantitative Approach.” Journal of Disaster Research, Volume 11(4): 691-698.
36. Ning, JingFeng, Zhiyu Chen and Gang Liu. 2010. “PDCA process application in the continuous improvement of software quality.” 2010 International Conference on Computer, Mechatronics, Control and Electronic Engineering: China.
37. Othman, Marini, Mohammad Nazir Ahmad, Azizah Suliman, Noor Habibah Arshad and Siti Sarah Maidin. 2014. “COBIT Principles to Govern Flood Management.” International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, Volume 9: 212-223.
38. Ridley, Gail, Judy Young and Peter Carroll. 2008. “Studies to Evaluate COBIT's Contribution to Organisations: Opportunities from the Literature.” Australian Accounting Review, Volume 18(4): 334-342.
39. Rohde, David, Jonathan Corcoran, Michelle Sydes and Angela Higginson. 2015. “The Association Between Smoke Alarm Presence and Injury and Death Rates: a Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.” Fire Safety Journal, 81:58-63.
40. Runefors, Marcus, Nils Johansson and Patrick van Hees. 2016. “How Could the Fire Fatalities Have Been Prevented? An Analysis of 144 Cases During 2011–2014 in Sweden: An Analysis.” Journal of Fire Sciences, Volume 34(6): 515-527.
41. Russoa, Rosaria de F. S. M. and Roberto Camanhob. 2015. “Criteria in AHP: a Systematic Review of Literature.” Procedia Computer Science, Volume 55:1123-1132.
42. Ryu, Chang-Su. 2015. “IoT-based Intelligent for Fire Emergency Response Systems.” International Journal of Smart Home, Volume 9(3): 161-168.
43. Saaty, Thomas L.. 1990. “How to Make a Decision: The Analytic Hierarchy Process.” European Journal of Operational Research, Volume 48: 9-26.
44. Saaty, Thomas L.. 2008. “Decision Making with the Analytic Hierarchy Process.” International Journal of Services Sciences, Volume 1(1): 83-98.
45. Saeed, Faisal, Anand Paul, Abdul Rehman, Won Hwa Hong and Hyuncheol Seo. 2018. “IoT-Based Intelligent Modeling of Smart Home Environment for Fire Prevention and Safety.” Journal of Sensors and Actuator Networks, Volume 7(11):1-16.
46. Sakurai, Mihoko, Yuko Murayama. 2019. “Information Technologies and Disaster Management – Benefits and Issues.” Progress in Disaster Science, Volume 2: 1-4.
47. Speight, Peter. 2011. “Business Continuity.” Journal of Applied Security Research, Volume 6(4): 529-554.
48. Supriadi, Leni Sagita Riantini and Low Sui Pheng. 2017. Business Continuity Management in Construction, Springer: Singapore.
49. Tammineedi, Rama Lingeswara. 2010. “Business Continuity Management: A Standards-Based Approach.” Information Security Journal: A Global Perspective,
Volume 19(1): 36-50.
50. Torabi, S.A., H.Rezaei Soufi and Navid Saheb Jamnia. 2014. “A New Framework for Business Impact Analysis in Business Continuity Management (with a case study).” Safe Science, Volume 68: 309-323.
51. Umar, Aminu, Mohamed Rashid Embia, Yahya Muhamad Yatimb, Ibrahim A. Alkalic. 2015. “Experts Influence on Fire Safety Criteria Ranking for Factory Buildings in Nigeria.” Jurnal Teknologi, Volume 77(14), 95-98
52. Watts, John M.. 1997. “Analysis of the NFPA Fire Safety Evaluation System for Business Occupancies.” Fire Technology, Volume 33(3): 276-282.
53. Wu, Yih‐Min, Da‐Yi Chen, Ting‐Li Lin, Chih‐Yih Hsieh, Tai‐Lin Chin , Wen‐Yen Chang, Wei‐Sen Li, Shaw‐Hsung Ker. 2013. “A High‐Density Seismic Network for Earthquake Early Warning in Taiwan Based on Low Cost Sensors.” Seismological Research Letters, Volume 84(6): 1048-1054
54. Xiao, Yu and Walter Gillis. 2014. “Do Hazard Mitigation and Preparedness Reduce Physical Damage to Businesses in Disasters? Critical Role of Business Disaster Planning.” Natural Hazards Review, Volume 15(3): 1-11.
55. Taylor, Mark, Deb Appleton, Guy Keen and John Fielding. 2019. “Assessing the Effectiveness of Fire Prevention Strategies.” Public Money and Management, Volume 39(6): 418-427.
56. Zhang, Shengnan and Hans Le Fever. 2013. “An Examination of the Practicability of COBIT Framework and the Proposal of a COBIT-BSC Model.” Journal of Economics, Business and Management, Volume 1(4): 391-395.