| 研究生: |
李宗勳 Li, Tzong-Shiun |
|---|---|
| 論文名稱: |
研發創新性表面溫度量測應用於診斷糖尿病足之血循病變 Develop an Innovative Surface Temperature Measuring to Diagnose Circulatory Disorder on Diabetic Foot |
| 指導教授: |
鍾高基
Chung, Kao-Chi |
| 學位類別: |
博士 Doctor |
| 系所名稱: |
工學院 - 生物醫學工程學系 Department of BioMedical Engineering |
| 論文出版年: | 2011 |
| 畢業學年度: | 100 |
| 語文別: | 英文 |
| 論文頁數: | 106 |
| 中文關鍵詞: | 糖尿病足 、血管供應區 、表面溫度 、末梢血管病變 、血管病變 |
| 外文關鍵詞: | Diabetic foot, Angiosome, Surface temperature, Peripheral occlusive disease, Vasculopathy |
| 相關次數: | 點閱:102 下載:1 |
| 分享至: |
| 查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報 |
現今社會日常生活型態的改變以及人口老化趨勢,導致全球第二型糖尿病之盛行率急劇增加。糖尿病為一種很複雜的疾病,隨著高血糖和蛋白糖化的進展促使急性及慢性併發症的產生。糖尿病足為非常嚴重的慢性併發症,包括神經性病變、血管病變,及血管合併神經性病變三大類型,其最後的結果皆會因血循灌流不足進而造成足部組織壞死甚至截肢。糖尿病足在早期發生的時候並不容易診斷,病人常因足部產生潰瘍,傷口不易癒合才來就診,此時足部可能已經產生不同程度的血循病變。臨床上,糖尿病患合併足部血循病變的時候,非侵入性的理學檢查扮演著早期篩檢的角色,但其精確度及信賴度經常被質疑。雖然最先進血管攝影可提供精確的足部血循供應診斷,但為侵入性且相當昂貴於第一線篩檢有較大的困難性。因此發展非侵入性及實惠的創新性診斷糖尿病足血循病變檢測方法成為目前相當重要及極具挑戰性的研究課題。
本研究的目的為研發實惠的創新性皮膚表面溫度量測用於診斷糖尿病足之血循病變,以達到早期診斷及早期治療進而限制殘障及續發疾病的目標。其特定目標為: (1)探討前足踝、足背、足底內側、足底外側、足跟和足踝外側的皮膚表面溫度分佈形態;(2)發展皮膚表面溫度測量檢測糖尿病足循環障礙的臨床檢測流程(Protocol);(3)評估此表面溫度檢測方法的準確性。足踝血管供應區(angiosomes)與血流於皮膚表面溫度之間的相關性提供本研究發展的理論基礎。本研究實驗分為兩個階段:第一階段受測者為五十位正常人(男女各25位,年齡46.1±7.8歲)與一百位糖尿病患(男女各50位,年齡61.3±9.4歲),所有受測者皆通過IRB於義大醫院及中國醫藥大學附設醫院,經由血管杜普勒感測器來定位前足踝、足背、足底內側、足底外側、足跟和足踝外側六個血管供應區塊,並利用高感度遠紅外線溫度感測器量測此六個供應區塊的皮膚表面溫度。分析表面溫度與血循病變之關聯性,推導出最具代表性區塊足背與足底內側表面溫度診斷流程(DPTR)。第二階段利用DPTR診斷糖尿病患者(其中糖尿病無足部血循病變19人,年齡52.1±5.2歲;糖尿病合併足部血循病變81人,年齡61.5±8.9歲)是否有足部血循病變,以血管攝影作為標準準則,使用敏感度(糖尿病患血管攝影有足部血循病變,並判為有糖尿病合併足部血循病變)、特異度(糖尿病患血管攝影無足部血循病變,並判為有糖尿病無足部血循病變)及Receiver operating characteristic(ROC)曲線分析,探討於早、中、晚三個時段表面溫度診斷之準確性,並制定其DPTR之診斷指標。
表面溫度量測結果顯示:(1)在正常族足背和足底內側所呈現的溫度分別為28.6±2.13度和29.3±2.46度,並測得DPTR為1.02±0.03;(2)糖尿病由血管攝影診斷出無足部血循病變之族群所呈現的溫度分別為29.8±4.03度和30.5±3.36度,並測得DPTR為1.03±0.06;(3)糖尿病由血管攝影診斷出有足部血循病變之族群所呈現的溫度分別為29.1±2.75度和28.1±2.99度,因此並測得DPTR為0.96±0.02;以足背和足底內側最具代表性。以血管攝影結果作為標準,利用統計學方式來完成表面溫度量測於臨床療效之ROC曲線分析,於早上測量之準確性較高,當DPTR小於等於0.997時,為糖尿病足合併血循病變,此時敏感度為96.3%和特異度為94.74%。綜合以上的研究成果,正常族與糖尿病族由於足背血管供應源頭為足背動脈,其週邊無太多的組織包覆,其表面溫度較低;由於體內每一部分組織血流量幾乎都是依據組織的需求大小而受到嚴密的控制,而足底內側的組織需求較高,導致表面溫較高,但於糖尿病有足部血循病變族群中,內蹠動脈最易堵塞且灌流下降,導致該區塊表面溫度較低,因此DPTR具有臨床診斷之意義。
本研究探討足部表面溫度變化於糖尿病足合併血循病變,可提供臨床應用的基礎資料,達到早期診斷及早期治療之目的。目前糖尿病足的成因已知有限,因此針對不同型態病變的診斷極為困難。本研究之初步結果可以提供發展非侵入糖尿病足診斷系統之規格參考。在未來之研究,仍需要進行大量的樣本數來進一步分析,以提供更精確的量測進而發展出全面性的監測系統來有效防止糖尿病足血循病變所帶來的威脅。
Lifestyle changes (e.g. eating habits) and increasing aging population have led to the dramatically increased prevalence of type II diabetes. Diabetes (DM) is a serious complicated illness; acute and/or chronic complications occur along with Hyperglycemia and Glycosylation development. Diabetic foot includes infection, ulceration and destruction of deep tissues associated with neurological abnormalities and various degrees of peripheral vascular disease in the lower limb. Neuropathy and/or Vasculopathy have eventually led to blood flow deficiency which causes tissue necrosis and even requires amputation. Physical examinations of claudication, cold sensation or absence of palpable peripheral pulses are commonly used to early detect the foot circulation problems. However, these methods may not identify diabetic foot patients in the early development stage. Angiography remains the gold standard for identifying peripheral arterial occlusive disease (PAOD) and areas of occlusion in the arterial system, but angiography is invasive, expensive and radiative. The purpose of this research was to develop innovatively a cost-effective/non-invasive/in vivo surface temperature measuring to diagnose circulatory disorder on DM foot. More specifically, this research was aimed to: (1) investigate the skin surface temperature patterns on anterior ankle, dorsum foot, medial plantar foot, later plantar foot, heel and lateral ankle regions; (2) develop a clinical protocol of surface temperature measuring to detect PAOD on diabetic foot; (3) evaluate the accuracy of this temperature test by analyzing sensitivity, specificity and receiver operating characteristic curve.
This research was divided into two stages of experiments. In the first stage, 50 normal subjects and 100 diabetic subjects, which were recruited and signed consented inform of IRB from E-DA Hospital (Taiwan)/China Medical University Hospital (Taiwan), were conducted skin surface temperature measurements by using a high sensitive infrared thermometer on anterior ankle, dorsum foot, medial plantar foot, later plantar foot, heel and lateral ankle regions located by a hand held Doppler sensor probe at morning, afternoon, night session. The surface temperature data were analyzed to derive Dorsal-Plantar Foot Superficial temperature ratio (DPTR) as the criteria of clinical diagnostic protocol for the circulatory disorder on diabetic foot. In the second stage, 81 DM subjects with PAOD and 19 DM subjects without PAOD, which were diagnosed by angiography, were conducted surface temperature measurements on dorsum foot and medial plantar foot regions with corresponding DPTR calculation at morning, afternoon, night session. The accuracy of the test based on DPTR < 1 for PAOD detection was determined by sensitivity, specificity and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve.
The results of skin surface temperatures show that (1) the surface temperatures on dorsum foot and medial plantar foot regions of normal group are 28.6±2.13°C and 29.3±2.46°C with corresponding DPTR = 1.02±0.03 at morning session; dorsum foot and medial plantar foot regions are the most representative among these six angiosomes on normal group; (2) the surface temperatures on dorsum foot and medial plantar foot regions of DM group without PAOD are 29.8°C±4.03°C and 30.5°C±3.36°C with corresponding DPTR = 1.03±0.06 at morning session; (3) The surface temperatures on dorsum foot and medial plantar foot regions of DM group with PAOD are 29.1°C±2.75°C and 28.1°C±2.99°C with corresponding DPTR = 0.96±0.02 at morning session. The results of accuracy analysis indicate that at morning session, the sensitivity is 96.3% and the specificity is 94.74% with ROC curve setting DPTR < 0.997 for circulatory disorder detection.
The surface temperature of the dorsal region is lower on normal patients and diabetic patients without PAOD for the reason that dorsalis pedis artery has less soft tissue embedded, which makes energy release rapidly. Tissues of the medial plantar region have higher demand on blood, and its temperature raise accordingly. Medial plantar artery is easy to be blocked on DM patients with PAOD, which causes the decrease in the blood circulation amount and decrease the temperature of dorsal region. Therefore, the diagnosis of DPTR < 1 is likely to be useful for PAOD screening test.
1. Type 2 Diabetes and Vascular Complications: A pathophysiologic view. Khaled A. Ahmed, Sekaran Muniandy, and Ikram S. Ismail Biomedical Research 2010; 21 (2): 147-155
2. 衛行政院衛生署(99年)國人十大死因統計
3. American Diabetes Association, 2011 report
4. Surgical Management of the Diabetic. Wayne J. Caputo, DPM, FACFAS. Foot.Wounds. 2008;20(3):74-83
5. Foot Problems in Diabetes: An Overview. Jan S. Ulbrecht, Peter R. Cavanagh, Gregory M. Caputo.Clin Infect Dis. (2004) 39 (Supplement 2): S73-S82
6. High prevalence of asymptomatically poor muscle perfusion of lower extremities measured in type II diabetes patients with abnormal myocardial perfusion. Lin CC, Ding HJ, Yen RF, Wang JJ, Ho ST, Kao A.J Diabetes Complications. 2003 Nov-Dec;17(6):365-8.
7. The Costs of Diabetes. Tseng Chin-Hsiao, MD, PhD : Department of Internal Medicine, National Taiwan University Hospital,Taipei, Taiwan(2009)
8. Critical limb ischemia . Denis Clement . J Vasc Surg 2007; 45(Suppl S): S5–67.
9. Atlas of the Diabetic Foot 2003 .N. Katsilambros, E. Dounis, P. Tsapogas and N. Tentolouris.
10. Merck manual(Section 3:Heart and blood vessel disorder /Chapter 4:occlusive peripheral arterial disease)
11. Dachun Xu, Jue Li, Liling Zou, Yawei Xu, Dayi Hu,Sherry L Pagoto, Yunsheng Ma: Sensitivity and specificity of the ankle–brachial index to diagnose peripheral artery disease: a structured review.Vascular Medicine 2010;15(5) 361–369
12. The Diabetic Foot. Stephanie Wu, David G. Armstrong, Lawrence A. Lavery and Lawrence B. Harkless .Contemporary Diabetes, 2006, 201-226
13. How To Diagnose Peripheral Arterial Disease .Kazu Suzuki. 2007. DPM, CWS VOLUME: 20 PUBLICATION DATE: Apr 01.
14. Peripheral Arterial Disease in People With Diabetes: American diabetes association. Diabetes care, Vol 26, number 12, Dec 2003
15. Attinger C, Cooper P, Blume P, Bulan E. :The safest surgical incisions and amputations applying the angiosome principles and using the Doppler to assess the arterial-arterial connections of the foot and ankle. Foot Ankle Clin. 2001 Dec ; 6(4):745-99
16. Clinical Anatomy by Systems: Richard Snell 2006
17. Sportspodiatry, Medical illustration,UK
18. WHO Technical Report Series, No. 646, 1980 (WHO Expert Committee on Diabetes Mellitus second report).
19. Diabetes 1994 to 2010: Global Estimates and Projections. McCarty D, Zimmet P. Melbourne, International Diabetes Institute, 1994.
20. Diabetic Somatic Neuropathies . Andrew J.M. Boulton, Rayaz A. Malik,Joseph C. Arezzo, Jay M. Sosenko.Diabetes Care June 2004 vol. 27 no. 6 1458-1486
21. PAOD Testing in Diabetic Patients. Holcomb, Susan Simmons .2004 issue of Nurse Practitioner
22. Role of community pharmacist in management and prevention diabetic foot ulcer and infections. Debjit Bhowmik, Chiranjib.B, Jitender Yadav, M.R.Chandira: Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research2009, 1 (1): 38-53
23. Assessment and Management of Foot Ulcers for People with Diabetes:Nursing Best Practice Guideline March 2005
24. Diabetes and Endocrinology , Medscapes CME 2011
25. The risk of foot ulceration i n diabetic patients with high foot pressure: a prospective study. Veves, A., Murray, H., Young, M.J. Diabetologia 35:660, 1992.
26. Classification of diabetic foot wounds. Lavery, L.A., Armstrong, D.G., Harkless, L.B. J. Foot Ankle Surg. 35:528–531, 1996.
27. Treatment of diabetic foot infections. Wagner classification, therapy, and outcome.Calhoun, J.H., Cantrell, J., Cobos, J., Lacy, J., Valdez, R.R., Hokanson, J., Mader, J.T. Foot Ankle 9:101–106, 1988.
28. Noninvasive evaluation of the peripheral arterial system in the diabetic lower extremity. Pomposelli, F.B. WB Saunders, Philadelphia, 1995.
29. Choosing a practical screening instrument to identify patients at risk for diabetic foot ulceration. Armstrong, D.G., Lavery, L.A., Vela, S.A., Quebedeux, T.L., Fleischli, J.G. Arch. Intern. Med. 158:289–292, 1998.
30. Diabetes Nurse Practitioner Guidelines Role and Scope and Practice.Jane Overland ,Belinda Brooks,Diabetes center ,RPAH
31. Plastic Surgery (8 Vol. set) Vol. 1,6 Stephen J. Mathes
32. Angiosomes of the Foot and Ankle and Clinical Implications for Limb salvage: Reconstruction, Incisions, and Revascularization. Attinger, Christopher E. M.D.; Evans, Karen Kim M.D.; Bulan, Erwin M.D.; Blume, Peter D.P.M.; Cooper, Paul M.D: PRS, June 2006 - Volume 117 - Issue 7S - pp 261S-293S
33. Skin temperature in the neuropathic diabetic foot . Edward J Boykoab Jessie H Ahronicd, Victoria L Stenselc.Journal of Diabetes and its Complication ,Volume 15, Issue 5, Pages 260-264 ,September 2001
34. Skin perfusion pressure measurement is valuable in the diagnosis of critical limb ischemia. Castronuovo, J.J., Adera, H.M., Smiell, J.M., Price, R.M. J. Vasc. Surg. 26:629–637, 1997
35. Grabb’s Plastic Surgery 6th edition 2006 Charles H. Thorne , Scott P. Bartlett, Robert W. Beasley , Sherrell J. Aston, Geoffrey C. Gurtner, Scott L. Spear
校內:2017-01-12公開