簡易檢索 / 詳目顯示

研究生: 朱芝嫺
Chu, Chih-Hsien
論文名稱: 希羅多德的斯庫提亞論述
The Scythian Logos of Herodotus
指導教授: 翁嘉聲
Ueng, Jia-Sheng
學位類別: 碩士
Master
系所名稱: 文學院 - 歷史學系
Department of History
論文出版年: 2021
畢業學年度: 109
語文別: 中文
論文頁數: 115
中文關鍵詞: 希羅多德斯庫提亞大流士習俗波希戰爭
外文關鍵詞: Herodotus, Scythia, Greek, Nomos, Darius
相關次數: 點閱:193下載:41
分享至:
查詢本校圖書館目錄 查詢臺灣博碩士論文知識加值系統 勘誤回報
  • 本論文係對希羅多德的《歷史》第四書有關斯庫提亞的文本進行探究。這敘述一半是介紹斯庫提亞地理、習俗及傳統的民族誌論述(希臘人統稱為nomos),另半則是大流士對斯庫提亞人發動大規模入侵,這是波斯第一次入侵歐洲。希羅多德的《歷史》經常被批評在希臘波斯戰爭敘述中,經常出現長篇民族誌敘述,偏離敘述主題,可靠性也常被懷疑。本論文將以中亞草原民族斯庫提亞人進行探索,證實其民族誌敘述十分可靠,也強調這民族誌敘述與軍事史敘述是緊密關連,因為斯庫提亞人是根據自己的nomos來設計戰略,迎接挑戰,並戰勝波斯。類似情形也發生在雅典人因為民主政治,得以運用海軍戰勝波斯,而斯巴達人嚴格的agoge(斯巴達教育訓練),培養出在溫泉關視死如歸、和在普拉鐵伊阿戰場堅定不移的無敵戰士。簡言之,什麼樣的nomos會產生什麼樣的戰士,會決定如何回應危機。

    論文第一章強調希羅多德如何運用愛奧尼亞啟蒙運動所強調的logos建立史學這新論述,特別強調前蘇格拉底哲學探索宇宙的arche,和希羅多德探索戰爭起源的aitie,兩者有諸多相似之處。第二章為波斯入侵斯庫提亞,主要是確定大流士遠征斯庫提亞的意義,以及斯庫提亞人如何根據民族性或nomos,回擊同樣來自中亞草原、但已經忘本的波斯人。第三章介紹希羅多德豐富的斯庫提亞民族誌內容,探討其起源、部落、祭儀以及戰事的種種,亦同時介紹現代考古成果,驗證希羅多德對於斯庫提亞的論述是多有所本;最後則是介紹兩位希臘「高貴野蠻人」,他們親善希臘文化,卻招來殺身之禍。在最後一章,希羅多德強調斯庫提亞人的「移動」與熱愛自由的精神結合,擊退波斯的入侵。而這場戰爭的勝利,也預示希臘人未來將成功擊退波斯入侵。

    This thesis is an attempt to make an inquiry into the Scythian Logos in the Book 4 of Herodotus’ Histories (4.1-144), and the relationship between the Scythian ethnography (4.1-82) and the military narrative of Darius’ campaign against Scythia (4.83-144). It will then extend the conclusion reached in the Scythian logos to the Histories as a whole.

    As the main theme of Histories is a research on the causes (aitie) of the Persian Wars, a detailed analysis of the relatively densely-structured and shorter Scythian Logos with a close reading of the text provides one with an excellent opportunity for a close observation on the relation between these two parts: ethnography of the Scythian people and the military history of Darius’ Scythian campaign, that brings us with a tentative conclusion that the custom and tradition (called nomos in Greek) of a people would influence how a people responded to the external crisis and how a war was conducted. What has been reached on the relationship between the ethnographical part and the military history part could then be applied, in a tentative way, to the Histories as a whole. Despite the various and lengthy ethnographies of Herodotus have often been criticized as not much more than entertaining digressions for no apparent purpose but high talks full of inaccuracies, they in fact constitute necessary and often accurate parts of the Histories as a whole.

    中文摘要 I 英文摘要 II 誌謝 IV 目錄 V 年表 1 地圖 2 第一章 希羅多德和他的《歷史》 3 第一節 前言 3 第二節 希羅多德的生平及時代 5 第三節 希羅多德的《歷史》 11 第四節 希羅多德《歷史》與希波克拉底斯醫學對斯庫提亞人的討論與比較 27 第二章 波斯入侵斯庫提亞 39 第一節 Acheimenid波斯帝國 39 第二節 遠征斯庫提亞:大流士的「歐洲計畫」 46 第三節 斯庫提亞人擊敗大流士 56 第三章 希羅多德的斯庫提亞民族誌論述 66 第一節 希羅多德的斯庫提亞民族誌 66 第二節 斯庫提亞的考古發現 81 第三節 斯庫提亞在希臘文化的意義:親希臘文化的Anacharsis和Skyles 92 第四章 大流士遠征斯庫提亞對波希戰爭的意義 102 第一節 評估斯庫提亞遠征與波希戰爭 102 第二節 結論 107 參考文獻 112

    原典
    Goodwin, William W et al. (ed. and trans.) Plutarch, De Herodoti malignitate. (John Wilson and son, Cambridge, 1874)
    ( http://data.perseus.org/texts/urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0007.tlg123.perseus-eng1)(取得時間:2020.09.20)
    Hippocratic Writings (Penguin Classics) Revised ed. Edition (ed. G. E. R. Lloyd) (Penguin Classics, NY/ London, 1984)
    Lucian of Samosata (trans. by H. W. Fowler and F. G. Fowler), (Loeb Classical Library, Heinemann, London & Cambridge, Mass, 1905).
    (http://lucianofsamosata.info/Anacharsis.html)(取得時間:2021.02.01)
    Strassler, Robert B.: The Landmark Herodotus. The Histories (Anchor Books, New York, 2009)
    參考文獻(Secondary Literature):
    Blundell, Susan: Women in Ancient Greece(Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1995)
    Boardman, John and N. G. L. Hammond (ed.) The Cambridge Ancient History (2nd edition). Vol. 3, Pt. 3. The Expansion of the Greek World, Eighth to the Sixth Centuries B.C.(CUP, Cambridge, 1982)
    Boardman, John and N. G. L. Hammond (ed.): The Cambridge Ancient History.(2nd edition) Vol. 4 Persia, Greece, and the Western Mediterranean, c. 525 to 479 B.C. (CUP, Cambridge, 1988)
    Cunliffe, Barry: The Oxford Illustrated Prehistory of Europe(Oxford University Press, New York, 1994)
    Fantham, Elain et al.: Women in the Classical World: Image and Text(Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1994)
    McInerey, Jeremy: A Companion to Ethnicity in the Ancient Mediterranean(John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, 2014)
    Moyer, Ian: “Herodotus and an Egyptian Mirage“ (Journal of Hellenic Studies) (122) 2002, pp.70-90.
    Murray, Oswyn & Alfonso Moreno: A Commentary on Herodotus Books I-IV( Oxford University Press, New York, 2007)
    Piotrovsky, Boris et al.: From the lands of the Scythians: Ancient treasures from the museums of the U.S.S.R. 3000 B.C.-100 B.C.(Metropolitan Museum NY Graphic Society, New York, 1975)
    Rolle, Renate: The World of The Scythians (B. T. Batsford, London, 1980)
    Rosalind, Thomas: “Introduction“, in The Landmark Herodotus The Histories Edited by Robert B. Strassler, pp. ix-xxxvi.(Anchor Books, New York, 2009)
    Wheeler, Everett L.: “Herodotus and the Black Sea Region“, in The Landmark Herodotus The Histories Edited by Robert B. Strassler (Anchor Books, New York, 2009), pp. 748-755.
    Wheeler, Everett L.: “Rivers and People of Scythia“, in The Landmark Herodotus The Histories Edited by Robert B. Strassler .(Anchor Books, New York, 2009), pp. 756-758
    Wheeler, Everett L.: “The Continuity of Steppe Culture“, in The Landmark Herodotus The Histories Edited by Robert B. Strassler(Anchor Books, New York, 2009), pp. 759-761
    中文資料
    奧爾巴哈著,張平男(譯),《模擬—西洋文學中現實的呈現》,(臺北市:幼獅,民69)。
    希羅多德著,王以鑄(譯),《歷史:希臘波斯戰爭史》,(臺北市:臺灣商務,民86)。
    張廣智,《西方史學史》,(台北市:五南,民91)。
    林俊雄,《草原王權的誕生》,(新北市:八旗文化出版社,民108)。
    翁嘉聲,〈希臘土生土長之憲章神話〉,《成大西洋史集刊》,第9期,臺南:國立成功大學歷史學系,1999。
    郭莉娟,〈古代希臘醫生-以《希波克拉底斯全集》所做之歷史重建〉,成功大學歷史系博士論文,2011。

    下載圖示 校內:立即公開
    校外:立即公開
    QR CODE